AP NEWS VS BLOGGERS OVER FAIR USE
AP News vs Bloggers Over Fair Use
Over the weekend I place up a hurried meaning link to a growing disceptation involving AP News and the blogosphere. actress Cadenhead, house of the Drudge Retort dispatched discover an email to fellow liberal bloggers late last week stating that he had conventional a “letter to the Drudge Retort asking it to vanish heptad items […]
Over the weekend I place up a quick meaning link to a growing disceptation involving AP News and the blogosphere. actress Cadenhead, house of the Drudge Retort dispatched discover an email to fellow liberal bloggers late last week stating that he had conventional a “letter to the Drudge Retort asking it to vanish heptad items that contained quotations from A.P. articles ranging from 39 to 79 words.”
On Saturday, The A.P. retreated. Jim Kennedy, vice chair and strategy director of The A.P., said in an interview that the programme methodicalness had decided that its letter to the Drudge Retort was “heavy-handed” and that The A.P. was going to rethink its policies toward bloggers.
The hurried about-face came, he said, because a sort of well-known bloggers started criticizing its policy, claiming it would undercut the astir discussion of the programme that rages on sites, bounteous and small, crossways the Internet.
Indeed, bloggers apace sprang into state with a planned boycott of AP News. A website and petition was created and the boycott has embellish a bi-partisan effort in the blogosphere thanks to plentitude of “bipartisan blogger buzz” over the weekend (h/t Newshoggers).
Rogers Cadenhead, of the Drudge Retort and individual another bloggers feature that ”the issue goes far beyond digit site.” It does in fact hit every bloggers.
“There are millions of grouping distribution links to programme articles on blogs, message boards and sites like Digg. If The A.P. has concerns that go every the way down to digit or two sentences of quoting, they requirement to tell grouping what they think is legal and where the boundaries are.”
On Friday, The A.P. issued a statement defending its action, locution it was going to contest journal postings containing excerpts of A.P. articles “when we feel the use is more sex than reference, or when others are encouraged to cut and paste.” An A.P. spokesman declined Friday to further explain the association’s position.
After that, however, the programme connexion convened a meeting of its executives at which it decided to suspend its efforts to contest blogs until it creates a more thoughtful standard.
“We don’t want to patch a dread over the blogosphere by existence heavy-handed, so we have to figure discover a meliorate and more constructive way to do this,” Mr. Kennedy said.
Now, the NY Times reports today that AP News has “said that it will, for the first time, endeavor to define country standards as to how much of its articles and broadcasts bloggers and Web sites crapper excerpt without infringing on The A.P.’s copyright.”
AP plans to “meet with representatives of the Media Bloggers Association, a trade group, and others” in discussions “so that guidelines crapper be free soon.”
AP News allegoric Mr. Kennedy said, “We are not trying to sue bloggers. That would be the wrinkled equivalent of suing grandma and the kids for stealing music. That is not what we are trying to do.”
But the planned guidelines from AP of “short summaries of A.P. articles kinda than direct quotations” still seems heavy-handed to bloggers. Michael Arrington notes on TechCrunch:
They do not want grouping quoting their stories, despite the fact that such state very understandably falls within the fair use exception to papers law. They verify that the state is an infringement.[…]
The A.P. doesn’t get to make it’s possess rules around how its noesis is used, if those rules are stricter than the law allows. So even thought they feature they are making these newborn guidelines in the spirit of cooperation, it’s country that, like the RIAA and MPAA, they are trying to nipper their way to a ordered of concept rights that don’t exist today and that they are not legally entitled to. And like the RIAA and MPAA, this is done to protect a dying playing model - paying content.
So here’s our newborn contract on A.P. stories: they don’t exist. We don’t wager them, we don’t excerpt them, we don’t link to them. They’re illegal until they abandon this newborn strategy, and I encourage others to do the aforementioned until they backwards down from these undignified attempts to stop the spread of information around the Internet.
I am encouraging every of our writers here to clew the Petition at UnassociatedPress.net and to make destined that they do not link to some AP stories which are widely distributed through many newspapers and newborn agencies.
There’s further discussion on this developing issue at: The Moderate Voice, Personal Democracy Forum, Outside The Beltway, Sweetness & Light, Althouse, The Carpetbagger Report, PoliBlog (TM), The Seminal, Concurring Opinions, Hot Air, Fausta’s blog, The Impolitic, The Glittering Eye, Macsmind, Connecting.the.Dots, Where Was I?, Gateway Pundit, Scott Rosenberg’s Wordyard, Bloggasm, Wake up America and The Other McCain.
And of instruction there’s a rank round-up of links at Memeorandum.
Tags: AP News, Bloggers, Blogosphere, Boundaries, Boycott, Broadcasts, Buzz, Controversy, Digg, Drudge Retort, Email, Excerpt, Excerpts, Jim Kennedy, N.Y. Times, News Association, News Organization, Pamela Leavey, Partisan Effort, Petition, Quick Reference, Quotations, Rages, Rogers Cadenhead, Sentences, Spokesman, Time Attempt
Source: feeds.feedburner.com
Biden tells it like it is
I love Joe Biden. I don’t speak of him too much on this blog, but the man is a hero in my book. Partly because he has no significance of semipolitical quality and doesn’t seem to be full of it…
Source: feeds.feedburner.com
Tags: asia\\\’s politics, gender and politics, politics 1830 philadelphia, importance of politics, tobacco industry and politics